What part of Windows is written in .Net/WPF/Silverlight?

user 曹一聪 on zhihu is curious how widely .Net is used within Windows components.

Obviously an operating system component cannot depend on something that isn’t in the operating system, so nothing uses Silverlight in the desktop version Windows. And because XP editions mostly did not ship with any .Net framework version, practically nothing from the XP days can use .Net. Only components newer than XP or rewrote after XP can use .Net, except those Windows Media Center and Tablet PC components that have .Net dependencies.

The first time .Net is available in almost all editions is Windows Vista/2008 (the server core editions make .Net optional). Because a Vista Capable sticker does not guarantee a machine with user-acceptable speed, not much in Windows Vista is using .Net. OR Windows 7 on that matter if you skip Windows Powershell. The usage of .Net is more in the consumer software (e.g. Windows Live Essentials), developer tools (e.g. Visual Studio) and business tools (e.g. SQL Server). In short, .Net is for writing apps, not really for the OS itself.

After Windows 8, Microsoft’s focus moved to Windows RT, now UWP, not much effort is done to improve the desktop, so practically nothing in the desktop got rewritten in .Net Framework.  Windows Help 2.0 is a notable exception however. Because more and more desktop components are moving to UWP (control panel, calculator, games etc), Windows 8 might be the peak of .Net Framework usage in Windows.

If you want a completed list of managed assemblies, you can just scan all dll/exe files on your system and see which file is a managed. And if a file is a managed assembly, search its references to find if WPF is used. AssemblyName.GetAssemblyName can detect a managed assembly file but it throws too many exceptions as most dll/exe files are not managed, so I use Meta Data APIs (IMetaDataDispenser/IMetaDataImport) to detect managed assemblies. The full code can be found at github.com/jiangsheng/Samples/blob/master/FindDotnetInWindows.

The initial list of managed files I found is pretty long so the scanner skip known locations that have known .Net assemblies, like the GAC, the .Net Framework folder, Windows Powershell, Visual Studio, SQL Server and  IIS. The usage of .Net in the rest of system is surprisingly sparse.  Windows itself is still a C/C++ stronghold.

About Sheng Jiang 蒋晟

Microsoft MVP in Visual C , 2004- Forum moderator of the Visual C and .Net forums on CSDN Forum moderator of Chinese forums on Microsoft's MSDN forums
This entry was posted in enmsdn, Microsoft and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s